Back

WKB Bohr-Sommerfeld vs Exact

What you are seeing: bound-state energies for a particle in a power-law well V(x)=xp/pV(x) = |x|^p / p, compared two ways. The blue ladder is the Bohr-Sommerfeld (WKB) approximation

The orange ladder is the "exact" answer: for the harmonic oscillator (p=2p = 2) we use the closed form En=n+12E_n = n + \tfrac12; for the quartic anharmonic oscillator (p=4p = 4) we use the published numerical eigenvalues from Bender and Wu (1969).

The Bohr-Sommerfeld rule is exact for the harmonic oscillator (a small miracle of the harmonic potential). For the quartic well it's an approximation that is excellent for nn large and noticeably wrong for n=0n = 0. Slide pp between 2 and 6 to watch the BS curve drift away from the analytic harmonic ladder.

Figure 1. Bohr-Sommerfeld (WKB) energy levels vs numerical shooting eigenvalues for V(x)=xp/pV(x) = |x|^p / p.
p2.00
n_max6

WHAT TO TRY

  • Start at p=2, the harmonic oscillator: the WKB and shooting ladders coincide exactly, because Bohr-Sommerfeld is exact for a quadratic potential and the connector lines lie flat.
  • Slide p up toward 6 so the well steepens toward a box: the two ladders pull apart, most at the ground state. The connector gap is the WKB error, and the readout shows it shrinking from tens of percent at n=0 to a fraction of a percent at the top level.
  • Raise n_max: more levels appear and the semiclassical trend is direct to read, WKB always converges to the true shooting eigenvalue as n grows, whatever the potential shape.