Back

Group vs Phase Velocity in a Dispersive Medium

What you are seeing: a real wave packet, a Gaussian band of wavenumbers added together, travelling through a dispersive medium. This is not a two-tone beat: the carrier crests (gold) move at the phase velocity $v_p = \omega/k_0$, the envelope (cyan) moves at the group velocity $v_g = \mathrm{d}\omega/\mathrm{d}k$, and the two trackers separate when they differ. When $v_p \ne v_g$ you can watch crests being born at one edge of the packet and dying at the other as it moves. And because $\omega(k)$ is curved, the components run at slightly different speeds and the packet spreads as it goes, the hallmark of dispersion that a fixed beat pattern can never show. The lower panel is the dispersion curve $\omega(k)$: the phase velocity is the slope of the chord from the origin, the group velocity is the slope of the tangent at $k_0$, so a straight relation gives $v_p = v_g$ (light) and a curved one makes them differ (deep water $v_g = v_p/2$, Schrödinger $v_g = 2v_p$, an anomalous branch where they point opposite ways).

Figure 1. A wave packet in a dispersive medium. Top: the carrier (v_p) and envelope (v_g) with their trackers; the packet spreads when ω(k) is curved. Bottom: the dispersion curve ω(k) with v_p as the chord slope and v_g as the tangent slope. Method: ψ(x,t) = Σ A(k) cos(kx − ω(k)t) over a Gaussian band; v_g = dω/dk by finite difference.
k_04.0
bandwidth σ_k0.50
dispersion

WHAT TO TRY

  • Watch a single crest: with deep water it races forward through the packet (v_p > v_g); with Schrödinger the packet outruns the crests (v_g > v_p) so crests drift backward through it.
  • Pick light: the chord and tangent coincide, v_p = v_g, the crests are frozen in the envelope and the packet does not spread.
  • Pick the anomalous branch: the tangent slopes down, v_g is negative, and the crest tracker and the packet move in opposite directions.
  • Widen the bandwidth σ_k: the packet gets shorter and spreads faster, since more wavenumbers means more spread in their phase speeds.